27 Comments
User's avatar
Sanjida Kay's avatar

This is so interesting. I'm definitely a plotter so I don't know how Lisa does it without having a bit of plot in place beforehand, especially as her books are quite twisty. I've just done a masterclass with Lee Child and he has the opening idea or question and an image. That's it! He says it's terrifying, like standing on top of a tall building every day. Lee also says he doesn't allow himself to go back and edit to make the plot work, he's just got to make it work given what he's already written. Mind blowing! About to look at your masterclass now JoJo!

Expand full comment
Yasmin Chopin's avatar

I’m reading the Reacher series at the moment. Want to learn more about Lee Child’s work.

Expand full comment
Sanjida Kay's avatar

Hi Yasmin, I've just started. I read Killing Floor and I absolutely love the Amazon Reacher series. Very sad I've now seen all the seasons. I can recommend Lee Child's BBC Masterclass. It's reasonably priced and I learned so much about his technique.

Expand full comment
Yasmin Chopin's avatar

Good to know about the masterclass Sanjida. Thanks.

Expand full comment
Katie Lee / KJ Lyttleton's avatar

Fascinating thanks JoJo! As a pantser trying to become a plotter, this was incredibly satisfying to read. I've been trying to switch because I convinced myself that it was a stupid way to write crime, but if it's good enough for Lisa Jewell, then it's good enough for anyone!

I'm going to go back and read my copy of Writing Into The Dark by Dean Wesley Smith and maybe embrace my inner pantser again.

Expand full comment
Sanjida Kay's avatar

I love it - embrace your inner pantser!

Expand full comment
Kim's avatar

Thanks for mentioning this book - just bought it in the hope that it can lift me out of plotting paralysis!

Expand full comment
Annie Macmanus's avatar

loved this. So helpful. And reassuring. The firing neurons! No! AI can't touch firing neurons!

Expand full comment
Helinka's avatar

What an enchanting conversation. I am a pantser and love it when the characters appear! Hats off!

Expand full comment
Jason Arehart's avatar

Such a great interview! Lisa’s method is so inspiring. I always try to plan my books, but I tend to veer away from the plan very quickly and end up pantsing my way through the back half. As Lisa suggests, it can be a painful, but very rewarding process.

Expand full comment
Lauren Elizabeth's avatar

Great interview. I'm definitely a pantser! If I tried to plot, then my writing just feels prescriptive and lacking. I like to discover my story in real-time with my characters.

Expand full comment
Robert Crouch's avatar

What fascinating interview. As a pantser I've struggled to understand and explain how it all works. But Lisa's explanations had me nodding away. Sometimes I've wondered if it's a sensible way to write crime, but it's great to know others work in similar ways.

Expand full comment
Bronwen Leigh's avatar

Fascinating. I may need to get a copy of The House We Grew Up In as I’m currently decluttering my house (and writing about it on here!) and helping my mum do the same with hers ahead of moving. I love this though - the difference between planning and pantsing - or character led work versus plot led. I think I plan the basics and love world building, then let the characters evolve as I go. But I’m just starting out. Thank you for this 💚

Expand full comment
Jill Mansell's avatar

Lisa’s method of writing is truly terrifying - it’s a good job she’s a genius!

Expand full comment
Musings of a Late Bloomer's avatar

Fascinating to read how other writers work. I'm a pantser, but I have a bit more of an arc in mind when I start than Lisa does. Whenever I try to plan more than that, though, I end up going in a diffrent direction anyway, so I've decided to embrace how I write and not waste time on that.

Expand full comment
Jilly WingitWriter's avatar

What an inspiring interview. I sit on the fence between pantser and plotter. I need some creative leeway. I sometimes sit down to write a chapter and it turns out different as I write it. Like it’s writing itself, so I get where Lisa is coming from, but the whole book - wow!

Expand full comment
Kate Braithwaite's avatar

Such a great conversation! I might enjoy Lisa’s books even more now I know how organic they are. Wow!

Expand full comment
Daisy Buchanan's avatar

I LOVED this, what a generous, inspiring and surprising conversation. Lisa's novels feel so stylish and so deliberate, so this has blown my mind.

Expand full comment
Alison Young's avatar

I find this fascinating. I’ve only ever written as it comes to me and I hated it at school when writing an essay we had to show our plan.

In my view I just get the best results when I just run with what enters my head.

When I belonged to a writing group of expats around a farmhouse table… we would write for 3 minutes with four or five random words picked from a book on a shelf. We would then read aloud what we’d come up with in three minutes. Always incredible… no planning but the genesis of fascinating stories. We would then flesh out a character by describing them as a piece of furniture or a car…. But strangely the six of us much preferred to just run with our unstructured thoughts and revel in our amazing imaginations.

Expand full comment
Yasmin Chopin's avatar

What lovely exercises.

Expand full comment
FranB's avatar

I love Lisa Jewell, but never expected she would be a pantser. As a pantser myself this is fabulous news!

Expand full comment
Elaine R. Frieman's avatar

Ha! Love this! So fascinating. 🫶🏻

Expand full comment